No. 19-555

R. Ray Fulmer, II v. Fifth Third Equipment Finance Company, et al.

Lower Court: Eighth Circuit
Docketed: 2019-10-30
Status: Denied
Type: Paid
Response Waived
Tags: asset-valuation bankruptcy-auction bankruptcy-code-section-363 bankruptcy-sale chapter-7 collateral-attack creditor-rights fiduciary-duties fiduciary-duty jurisdictional-error non-jurisdictional-error priority-distribution priority-violation priority-violations
Latest Conference: 2020-01-10
Question Presented (from Petition)

11 U.S.C. §363(m) moots claims against good faith purchasers at bankruptcy auctions if the claims invalidate the sale. In this case, the court's nonappealable approval of a §363 sale of the debtor's assets transferred $106 million in priority-violating distributions to preferred creditors and nonpurchasers. The 6,000 non-preferred creditors received nothing. The court converted the proceeding to Chapter 7 and appointed a trustee four months post-sale. Petitioner sued the debtor's fiduciaries, Creditor Committee members and other non-purchasers for damages arising from their pre- and post-petition concealment of false asset valuations and breach of contractual and fiduciary duties owed to the debtor. Some of the false valuations were used to score the auction bids. The court dismissed the entire damages suit as an impermissible collateral attack on a final sale order. The Eighth Circuit affirmed, holding in part that the priority violations were non-jurisdictional errors.

Two related questions are presented:

Whether a final 11 U.S.C. §363 sale order that distributes assets in violation of priority is unenforceable due to jurisdictional error; and

Whether §363(m) bars damages claims against non-purchasers arising from duties existing and breached independent of a §363 sale, and which would not overturn the sale result or the sale approval order.

Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether a final 11 U.S.C. §363 sale order that distributes assets in violation of priority is unenforceable due to jurisdictional error

Docket Entries

2020-01-13
Petition DENIED.
2019-12-11
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 1/10/2020.
2019-11-25
Waiver of right of respondent Ryder Integrated Logistics, Inc. to respond filed.
2019-11-20
Waiver of right of respondent Fifth Third Equipment Finance Company to respond filed.
2019-11-13
Waiver of right of respondents 412 Inc., f/k/a Sager Creek Vegetable Company, Sankaty Credit Opportunities IV, L.P., et al. to respond filed.
2019-11-08
Waiver of right of respondent Teneo Securities, LLC to respond filed.
2019-11-07
Waiver of right of respondent URS Real Estate,LP to respond filed.
2019-11-07
Waiver of right of respondent Syngenta Seeds, Inc. to respond filed.
2019-11-05
Waiver of right of respondent Ball Metalpack, LLC, f/k/a Ball Metal Food Container LLC to respond filed.
2019-11-05
Waiver of right of respondent Cortland Capital Market Services, LLC to respond filed.
2019-11-01
Waiver of right of respondent International Paper Company to respond filed.
2019-10-24
Petition for a writ of certiorari filed. (Response due November 29, 2019)

Attorneys

412 Inc., f/k/a Sager Creek Vegetable Company, Sankaty Credit Opportunities IV, L.P., et al.
John Edward RobertsProskauer Rose LLP, Respondent
Andrew Torgove, et al.
Gordon Dwyer ToddSidley Austin LLP, Respondent
Ball Metalpack, LLC, f/k/a Ball Metal Food Container LLC
Charles F. Smith Jr.Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, Respondent
Cortland Capital Market Services, LLC
Barbra Rachel ParlinHolland & Knight LLP, Respondent
Fifth Third Equipment Finance Company
Lloyd A. LimReed Smith, LLP, Respondent
International Paper Company
Bruce D. BuechlerLowenstein Sandler LLP, Respondent
R. Ray Fulmer, II
Whitney Aaron DavisLaw Office of Whitney A. Davis, Petitioner
Ryder Integrated Logistics, Inc.
John T. Carroll IIICozen O'Connor, Respondent
Syngenta Seeds, Inc.
David H. ConawayShumaker, Loop & Kendrick, LLP, Respondent
Teneo Securities, LLC
Michael Glen SmithDover Dixon Horne PLLC, Respondent
URS Real Estate,LP
Scott Ernest TaylorArnall Golden Gregory LLP, Respondent