No. 25-310

J.A. Masters Investments, et al. v. Eduardo Beltramini

Lower Court: Fifth Circuit
Docketed: 2025-09-17
Status: Denied
Type: Paid
Tags: diversity-jurisdiction due-process erie-doctrine force-majeure impossibility-defense jury-instructions
Latest Conference: 2025-11-21
Question Presented (from Petition)

1. Whether a federal court sitting in diversity may deny
a party the right to present the equitable defense of
impossibility to the jury—despite uncontroverted
evidence and the absence of any express waiver—
solely because the contract contains a one-sided force
majeure clause that is silent on equitable defenses, in
direct conflict with the decisions of the Fourth and
Seventh Circuits and in violation of the Fifth and
Seventh Amendments.

2. Whether a federal court may disregard mandatory
state jury instructions, particularly those related
to the legally required measure of damages under
substantive state law (Texas), in diversity cases
without violating the litigant's rights to due process
and a fair trial under the Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendments and the Erie doctrine.

3. Whether federal courts may categorically preclude
invocation of impossibility and frustration-of-purpose
defenses based on boilerplate force majeure clauses—
regardless of waiver or contract structure—thereby
eliminating equitable defenses long recognized by law
and equity and creating a sharp division among the
circuits on the treatment of pandemic-related contract
disputes.

Question Presented (AI Summary)

Whether a federal court sitting in diversity may deny a party the right to present the equitable defense of impossibility to the jury despite uncontroverted evidence and the absence of any express waiver solely because the contract contains a one-sided force majeure clause that is silent on equitable defenses

Docket Entries

2025-11-24
Petition DENIED.
2025-11-05
DISTRIBUTED for Conference of 11/21/2025.
2025-06-02
Petition for a writ of certiorari filed. (Response due October 17, 2025)
2025-04-30
Application (24A937) granted by Justice Alito extending the time to file until June 2, 2025.
2025-04-24
Application (24A937) to extend further the time from May 3, 2025 to June 2, 2025, submitted to Justice Alito.
2025-03-31
Application (24A937) granted by Justice Alito extending the time to file until May 3, 2025.
2025-03-22
Application (24A937) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of certiorari from April 3, 2025 to June 2, 2025, submitted to Justice Alito.

Attorneys

J.A. Masters Investments
Ernest G. IanettiAttorney at Law, Petitioner