Article IV standing requirement. Respondent failed to establish federal question jurisdiction, which made the controversy non-justiciable. Article III of the Constitution and the one-year rule of the Circuit Court of Appeals case 2M-2299 apply. The District Court consolidated cases on 07/30/[year] and Article III motion for appeal was denied. This is case 2002-2002 consolidated case 2M-2299. The Court of Appeals decided each case in the Circuit Court. The District Court decided to hear Article III case 06/2M-2299 because the Certificate of Appeal was denied under case 2029-2002.

Whether the district court's denial of habeas corpus relief under 28 U.S.C. § 2254 was proper after appellate review