Edwin Cortorreal v. United States
Punishment Privacy JusticiabilityDoctri
1. Whether a criminal defendant has prudential standing
to enforce an extradition decree that is issued for his own benefit
where the government concedes that the decree codifies a promise
made to the defendant by a judge in the surrendering nation . The
Second Circuit held in this case that such a decree, and the promise it
codifies, is not within the defendant's "own rights and interests" and
that he therefore lacks prudential standing to enforce it .
2. Whether, under this Court's precedent in United States
v. Rauscher , 119 U.S. 407 (1886), a criminal defendant has standing
to assert violations of the rule of specialty without requiring the
surrendering nation to intervene .
Whether a criminal defendant has prudential standing to enforce an extradition decree that is issued for his own benefit where the government concedes that the decree codifies a promise made to the defendant by a judge in the surrendering nation