I. Whether the denial of Mr. Madero's appeal to
Respondent's motion for summary judgment was in
error, under this Court's ruling in Tolan , as there
was a genuine dispute of material fact and the
evidence of the nonmovant was not believed.

II. Whether the denial of Mr. Madero's appeal regarding
lack of probable cause at the time of his arrest
violates the Fourth Amendment, and is contradictory
to this Court's findings in Beck and Llaguna .

Whether the denial of Mr. Madero's appeal to Respondent's motion for summary judgment was in error, under this Court's ruling in Tolan, as there was a genuine dispute of material fact and the evidence of the nonmovant was not believed