I. Did the First Circuit Court of Appeals error in granting summary judgment to both Triple-S Management Corporation and Triple-S Vida based solely on a single merits defense claim?

II. Did the First Circuit Court of Appeals error by deciding on the admissibility of nonmovants' evidence before determining if there was a genuine issue of material fact, and subsequently, weighing the evidence thus causing a conflict in the Circuit Courts?

III. Did the Circuit Court of Appeals error in failing to consider whether Bonner had enough time to complete discovery before it upheld the District Court's grant of summary judgment, despite incomplete discovery and requests from all parties to extend the discovery period evidencing a split between the circuit courts.

Did the First Circuit Court of Appeals err in granting summary judgment to Triple-S Management Corporation and Triple-S Vida based solely on a merits defense claim?