1. Whether the Puerto Rico Supreme Court
erred and violated the presumption against
retroactivity and procedural due process
when it retroactively applied the Rules of the
Puerto Rico Appellate Court for the review of
administrative determinations to the review
procedures for arbitration awards filed before
the CFI's which until HIMA's underlying case
before the CFI, had been subject to different
procedural rules applicable in said forum, and
summarily reinstated the arbitration awards
without allowing any recourse for review.

2. Whether the Puerto Rico Supreme Court erred
in failing to affirm the PRCA and find that HIMA
had timely filed and paid the corresponding filing
fees for at least one (1) appeal of the arbitration
awards granted by the CAB's Arbitrator.

Whether the Puerto Rico Supreme Court erred and violated the presumption against retroactivity and procedural due process