I.
Whether Congress Under the Healthcare Quality
Improvement Act (HCQIA) Intended Only to Protect Reporting Physicians and Entities to the
"Physicians' Blacklist," the National Practitioner
Data Bank (NPDB) Because They Were the "Intended Class" to Benefit From Reporting and
Tracking Potentially
Dangerous
Physicians
Across State Lines.

II.
Whether the Lower Courts Flagrantly Disregarded Examining Evidence Under HCQIA and
Erroneously Awarded Respondents Judgment on
the Pleadings or in the Alternative Summary
Judgment as a Matter of Law.

III. Whether the Lower Courts, Misled by Judicial
Analysis Under HCQIA applied bad case law to
guide its conclusion.

Whether Congress intended HCQIA to protect reporting physicians and entities to the National Practitioner Data Bank