1. Abbednee toe Slate Covort decrvgor Patt "here v3 NO Beguiremeut Hye Court ufoven Hae ly <feadanit of tHe Elemieats of @ach Chinogs" Coatrory to Suprente Coork Lame? ;

A. dlhelace Ye Fedunl rshared Coort Reso lotion of Pet beontan's Chaitin Conmflieds LALin Telroeln Vi Darcled Slates, 89 8.c+ IL6b (1464) and Lytle States Ui Ametterlin, 1% Sick 1044 (ara) 7 .

3 Whicthe. Hac Fuderal Pisda'et Covet Onzid of \yused tbs discize ti'on lathare vt focled to deter Trte Lyot Poh sonar kad miede 1 Bobs leactosl Shovuit, of w deavint of a Consttotroual Baht AS Brqusesd Ly ag Us.c.8re, 99590) 0) Latent Seahing to obtais a C.0.8.7 .

UY Albethe Mme Clevcadthy Cercort Court of Appents cre OR Al used its discretion oh Requied tare Vivien fo Shaw thst funst of Rensow Ulovid Lind debate ble bots (1) "the mers of war Lasderly ing Clade" pad (a) "he proce dural USSUES le Secs YO Rosse') ow onder to Obtacm wa Cow Wace Clan Yas deed om the tea 7

Cried oR Abused Shs desciedlou an deste tate, Pell. once's Dyotca Lon Releaning |

Whether the Federal District Court erred in dismissing Petitioner's claims contrary to Supreme Court precedent