Whether the First Circuit erred in holding—
1.
in direct conflict with the Illinois Supreme
Court and in conflict with four other circuit
courts of appeals—that a recording law which
makes it a felony for individuals to secretly
record under any circumstances is not facially
overbroad under the First Amendment.

Whether the First Circuit erred in holding—
2.
in direct conflict with five other circuit courts
of appeals—that a party challenging a speecharticulate every type of contemplated speech
activity to satisfy ripeness for as-applied challenges.

Whether the First Amendment protects the right to secretly record oral communications