Whether the Due Process Clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution were violated to deny Petitioners a fair trial due to the bias of the presiding judge when, cumulatively:

1. In her preliminary instructions to the jury the presiding judge instructed the jury to find for the plaintiffs, tDuring the trial, the presiding judge admonished the defendants an inordinate and unconscionable number of times, at least seventeen, in the presence of and not in the presence of the jury;

2. During the trial, the presiding judge sustained the objections of counsel for plaintiffs, an inordinate and unconscionable number of times, at least one hundred thirteen, in the presence of and not in the presence of the jury.

3. During the trial, the judge unfairly and prejudicially allowed testimony from a witness to show a pattern to a prior case in which the

Whether the Due Process Clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments were violated to deny Petitioners a fair trial due to the bias of the presiding judge