1. May an United States District Judge construe legal argument for a party in a civil rights lawsuit, an argument that we forty itself never wisely in a

(2) Did Honorable Henry R Herlono arwronf for Sheriff Chwto l/nfiM, We H'!Yi.KvVivl ?

(3) Can circumstantial evidence create an issue of materially lowering summary judgment

(4) Did the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit remission of law in District Court to assess credibility on a summary judgment motion and to decide implied factly. Construe such in Urbh mi L

Whether the district court properly construed the legal argument for a party in a civil rights lawsuit, and whether the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals improperly allowed the district court to discount credibility on summary judgment