1) Does The West Virginia State Tax Commissioner Dale Steager have an illegal obligation pursuant to West Virginia Code § 1-5, to concede the petitioner's misconduct on part of 0 was securing attorney's fees without maintaining the appropriate remedy in that West Virginia State Tax Commissioner fails to declare his action, duty provided Code was duty to take such actions necessary to sue. Due petitioners is chords due constitutional right of due process of law under the fourteenth amendment?

2) Does The West Virginia Supreme Court have a duty to apply the rule of law in issuing clearing abuse of mandamus?

3) Did The West Virginia Supreme Court apply rule of mandamus in appendix-A?

Does the West Virginia State Tax Commissioner Dale Steager have a legal obligation pursuant to the West Virginia Code § 11-1-5, to provide the petitioner Rickey Morgan a refund on his overpayment of taxes?